- Extell Development Co. Plan
- UNITY Community Dev. Plan
- Community Design Principles
- Agreements
- Contact Elected Officials
- Economic Analyses & Documents
   > IRS Bond Regulations
- Environmental Documents
- Legal Documents
   > Eminent Domain Lawsuit
   > EIS Lawsuit
   > MGPP Lawsuit
   > MTA Lawsuit
- Letitia James Remixed
- Letters
- Memoranda of Understanding
- News Articles/Commentary
- Position Papers
- Times Report
- White Papers
- MTA RFP & Appraisal
tel/fax: 718.362.4784

Please note our new postal address when sending contributions to the legal fund:
121 5th Avenue, PMB #150
Brooklyn, New York 11217
About DDDB
Our coalition consists of 21 community organizations and there are 51 community organizations formally aligned in opposition to the Ratner plan.

DDDB is a volunteer-run organization. We have over 5,000 subscribers to our email newsletter, and 7,000 petition signers. Over 800 volunteers have registered with DDDB to form our various teams, task-forces and committees and we have over 150 block captains. We have a 20 person volunteer legal team of local lawyers supplementing our retained attorneys.

We are funded entirely by individual donations from the community at large and through various fundraising events we and supporters have organized.

We have the financial support of well over 3,500 individual donors.

More about DDDB...
ARCHIVES: By Date| By Category| Text Search
"Why should people get to see plans? This isn't a public project."
Bruce Ratner in Crain's Nov. 8, 2009

NY State Never Sought Piece of Barclays Center Naming Rights Action

Ratner's frivolous $950 million arena would supposedly be "privately owned" (it would be leased to Ratner for $1), yet the $400 million naming rights deal with Barclays bank (is it still $400 million?) is solely with the developer. The public gets nothing out of the lucrative naming rights deal on the arena it supposedly owns.

Norman Oder did some FOIA searching to find out if NY State ever wisely tried to get any value out of the naming rights deal. What he found was that New York State was not wise. The state sure could have used that money.

From Oder on his Atlantic Yards Report:
Did the state try to gain any value from arena naming rights? Apparently not

Yesterday, Gov. David Paterson proposed $5.2 billion in budget cuts over the next 16½ months, with reductions in school aid, increased tuition at city and state universities, and reduced Medicaid reimbursements, among other things.

Perhaps administration officials--many of whom were not in charge at the time, actually--are wondering why exactly their predecessors allowed Forest City Ratner to claim the entire value of naming rights for the Barclays Center arena.

In response to a Freedom of Information Law request, documents received from the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) indicated that no effort was made to retain any such value, though at one point, a Forest City Ratner executive indicated anxiety about the developer being "punished" for the naming rights deal.

Why it matters

The arena would be publicly owned, formally at least, and leased to FCR for $1 a year. The main reason for the fig leaf of public ownership is to allow the issuance of tax-exempt bonds.

Still, it's not the developer's property, As author Neil deMause told me earlier this year, "There’s no reason for this [naming rights] to be private money."

But allowing the team owner to retain naming rights was apparently an unspoken component of the Atlantic Yards agreement. As Andrew Alper, then-president of the New York City Economic Development Corporation, told City Council 5/4/04:
So, they came to us, we did not come to them. And it is not really up to us then to go out and try to find a better deal.

(Note that the $400 million deal apparently must be renewed by the end of the month, and renewal--at least at that level--is hardly certain.)

Digging in

In September, I contacted the ESDC, asking:
Under the Freedom of Information Law, I request records regarding any discussion between the Empire State Development Corporation and developer Forest City Ratner (or any of its affiliates) regarding naming rights for the planned Atlantic Yards arena, now expected to be called the Barclays Center.

More specifically, I seek records that describe whether or not the ESDC attempted to ensure that the public received some value for the naming rights. I also seek records that explain the ESDC's rationale in allowing developer Forest City Ratner (or any of its affiliates) to control the naming rights.


The response

There were no real answer to the question about the ESDC's rationale.

In response, I got a six-page file (PDF) of email messages, part of which consisted of a message I myself sent and the ensuing ESDC response. Notably, none of the documents were dated before 2007, meaning that the issue was not discussed before the ESDC board approved the project in December 2006.

I filed a similar request with the New York City Economic Development Corporation, Alper's agency, which also participated in the initial Memorandum of Understanding for the project. I was told there were "no responsive documents."

Redacted documents

Though the documents are scant, in several places they were redacted; the ESDC cited exemptions that allow agencies to deny access to records that are inter-agency or intra-agency materials which are not final agency policy or determinations and instructions to staff that that affect the public, among other things.

The six pages

The documents consist of the following:

Page 1. A 1/16/07 email from ESDC President Avi Schick asking staffers, "In the KPMG analysis, what was the dollar amount assumed that Ratner would received for the arena naming rights?"

(The answers are redacted, but the KPMG report, released during litigation over the AY environmental review, assessed "sponsorship/naming rights" at $31.2 million. The Barclays Center deal announced 1/18/07 is said to be $20 million a year, but Forest City Ratner has since announced numerous other partnerships. KPMG did say that the $31.2 million figure may be on the high side.)

Page 2-4. A 1/22/07 email from me to then-spokeswoman Jessica Copen asking why, if the arena is publicly owned, why the Local Development Corporation (LDC) wasn't selling naming rights

Again, some internal messages were redacted; nor was Copen's answer included in this file. Her answer did not exactly address the issue, given the significant public support for the arena: "Financing for the stadium comes ultimately from the team. The team has the naming rights. It's the same deal as with the Mets - who also sold naming rights to their new stadium."
...
Continue reading to find out what former Atlantic Yards head honcho Jim Stuckey was worried about (hint, he was worried about being "punished" for the naming rights deal by the state by losing public subsidies.)



Posted: 11.14.08
DDDB.net en español.
Battle for Brooklyn
Screening Schedule

Battle Fore Brooklyn
Unity 4 Community Meeting, June 15th at 388 Atlantic Avenue

Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn on Facebook

Click here
to order DDDB tshirts. They cost $20 and all funds go to our legal campaign, shirts come in black, red, gold and pink tanktops.

Eminent Domain Case
Goldstein et al v. ESDC
[All case files]

November 24, 2009
Court of Appeals
Ruling

[See ownership map]

EIS Lawsuit

DDDB et al v ESDC et al
Click for a summary of the lawsuit seeking to annul the review and approval the Atlantic Yards project.

Appeal briefs are here.

2/26/09
Appellate Divsion
Rules for ESDC
What would Atlantic Yards Look like?...
Photo Simulations
Before and After views from around the project footprint revealing the massive scale of the proposed luxury apartment and sports complex.

Click for
Screening Schedule
of
Isabel Hill's
"Atlantic Yards" documentary
Brooklyn Matters


Read a review
-----------------------
Atlantic Yards
would be
Instant
Gentrification
Click image to see why:


-No Land Grab.org

-Atlantic Yards Report
-Atlantic Yards Deathwatch
-The Footprint Gazette
-Brooklyn Matters
-Noticing New York
-NY Times "The Local" FG/CH
-Brooklyn Views
-Council of B'klyn N'hoods
-The Brooklyn Paper
-The Brooklyn Wire
-Atlantic Lots
-Who Walk in Brooklyn
-S. Oxford St. Block Assoc.
-City Limits City Blogs
-The Knickerblogger
-Anyplace, Brooklyn
-Bklyn Bridge Park Defense
-Bay Ridge Journal
-Clawback
-Picketing Henry Ford
-Castle Coalition Blog
-Dope on the Slope
-Gowanus Lounge
-Fans For Fair Play
-Views from the Bridge
-Old First Blog
-DailyHeights.com
-Brooklyn Footprints
-Freddys Bklyn Roundhouse
-Ctr for the Study of Bklyn
-Pardon Me for Asking
-Clinton Hill Blog
-Only The Blog Knows BK
-Brownstoner
-Sustainable Flatbush
-A Child Grows in Bklyn
-Williamsburg Warriors

-The Real Estate
-Rail Yards Blog (H. Yards)
-OnNYTurf-Atlantic Yards
-Manhattan User's Guide
-Naparstek
-Streets Blog
-Urban Place & Space
-New York Games
-Field of Schemes
-News 12 Brooklyn
-Queens Crap
-Dist.35 Comm'ity Gazette
-Save Our Parks (Bronx)
-Eminent Domain Watch
-NJ Eminent Domain Law
-PLANYC
-Big Cities Big Boxes
-www.DANDOCTOROFF.com
-Olympic Bloomdoggle
-TenantServices.com
-Tenant.net